7 Mistakes Everyone Makes When Picking Paint Colors

We independently research, test, review, and recommend the best products—learn more about our process. If you buy something through our links, we may earn a commission.

Ready, set...go pick out a paint color you'll want to live with for years! OK, maybe slow down a minute for this design decision, which is one of the hardest to make. When we analyze a tiny paint chip, it's hard for us to imagine how the color will look once brushed across an entire wall. And forget about envisioning how the hue might change in varying types of light. Since the human brain is pretty bad at imagining how a paint color will look, carefully testing out paint swatches before buying a gallon is the best way to avoid painter's remorse. To learn the right way to pick out paint colors—and the mistakes to avoid—we asked the paint pros. According to the experts, here are seven common mistakes people make when choosing paint colors, plus what to do instead.

Making the Decision Too Quickly

Seriously, take a few days to decide between paint swatches. Not because you may change your mind over time (although that's a definite possibility), but because the color will change with the light throughout the day. And it will look different on a cloudy day versus a sunny day.

"Apply multiple colors and sit with them for a few days," recommends Erika Woelfel, Behr color expert. "Test them in multiple different parts of your room with different lighting to help you to better visualize what the color will look like in your space at any time of day."

Nicole Gibbons, the founder and CEO of Clare, shares similar advice: "Make sure you love your color both under daylight and in the evening when the sun is down and the artificial lights are on in your home," she says. Luckily, Clare offers repositionable swatches (that are like large stickers) so you can move them around to different walls and brighter or dimmer areas of the room.

"Once you've spent time with each color, then make your final choice. This can save you a lot of frustration and money in the long run," says Sue Wadden, director of color marketing at Sherwin-Williams. Taking your time now will help you avoid regrets later.

Not Considering the Furniture & Decor

Avoid testing swatches in a completely empty room. Even if you just moved in or want to empty the room before you start painting, keeping some furniture and decor in the room as you select a paint color will ensure the hue works with the other colors in the space.

"We always recommend painting a small board or piece of foam core and evaluating the color in different parts of the room and throughout the day," says Andrea Magno, Director of Color Marketing and Development for Benjamin Moore. "This will enable you to see how the color looks with consideration of the light (both natural and artificial) and other surroundings (such as artwork, furniture, etc.), ensuring that you'll love the color in all scenarios," she explains.

Placing Samples Right Next to Each Other

Farrow & Ball

While you should definitely sample multiple color options, avoid painting the samples right next to each other on the same wall, advises Patrick O'Donnell, International Brand Ambassador at Farrow & Ball. "They will distract each other (and you!) and make it harder to make a clear choice," he says.

"If you don't want to paint the area directly, paint the length of a large sheet of lining paper, and it becomes a movable feast that you can see on different walls in the same room and at different times of the day!"

Not Considering the Undertone

When you're looking at various shades of white paint, some appear to contain a hint of yellow, while others appear slightly blue. That subtle underlying color is called the undertone.

Magno suggests considering how the undertones of a paint color might draw out similar tones found in the furniture and decor throughout the room. "In addition to sampling the color in the space, compare similar shades that have different undertones (e.g., warm vs. cool) to help determine the best choice for the space."

Not sure if a paint color has a warm or cool undertone? Try this trick from Woelfel: "If you're unsure about the undertone of a particular shade of white (whether it contains a touch of yellow, peach, blue or green) try placing your color swatch on a piece of white paper."

Shying Away from Bold Hues

Pantone's 2022 Color of the Year

According to Woelfel, one of the biggest mistakes people make when choosing paint is simply being afraid to decorate with color. Especially when you're selecting paint samples, don't shy away from a bolder hue. After all, Pantone's 2022 Color of the Year is a "courageous" shade of blue.

Choosing Too Many Paint Colors

While you shouldn't be afraid to decorate with color, adding too many paint colors to the same room can be distracting.

"When it comes to placing paint colors in a room, less is more!" says O'Donnell. "Too many can lessen the impact. If you desire texture and contrast, focus more on using fabrics and artwork to bring in additional layers and character," he suggests.

Was this page helpful?