We’ve scoured hundreds of products to find these must-have gifts that you can personalize.

By Madison Alcedo
Updated January 15, 2019
Each product we feature has been independently selected and reviewed by our editorial team. If you make a purchase using the links included, we may earn commission.

Shopping for your significant other is hard enough any time of the year, but it’s especially tough during Valentine’s Day—you don’t want something overly cheesy, but it’s still a good day to remind someone you love them with a special gift.

Thanks to the online retailer, UncommonGoods, and its mission of connecting “makers and their creations with individuals looking for truly special goods regardless of the physical distance between the maker and the shopper,” you can shop special Valentine’s Day gifts (some that you can personalize!) for all your loved ones—in one place.

UncommonGoods is not only known for its more customized, handmade gifts, but they offer an amazing selection of everyday home essentials that most people don’t think to buy for themselves, but totally should (say hello to this handy cookbook stand and this soothing lavender pillow). Plus, what's even better about shopping at UncommonGoods is the retailer's new free shipping program called Uncommon Perks. At just $19 per year, shoppers can receive free standard shipping on all orders after signing up.

This Valentine’s Day, get your loved ones something special they’ll actually want to use (and that’s actually affordable!). Below we’ve rounded up some of our favorite Valentine’s Day gift ideas that you can personalize from UncommonGoods.


Personalized Hearts Four-Across Game

Make date night a game night with this custom-made game. Up to four lines of the board can be customized with names, anniversaries, or a sweet message.

To buy: $75; uncommongoods.com.


Date Night Bucket List

Never be without a new idea for your date nights again. Once you’ve completed each adventure, don’t forget to write the date on the back.

To buy: $18; uncommongoods.com.


Personalized Faux Bois Vase

For two lovebirds, this stoneware clay vase is completely customizable with whatever initials you want. It’s one of our favorite customized gifts from UncommonGoods since each piece will look unique, thanks to the artist’s carved pattern that’s made to resemble the winding furrows of a tree’s bark.

To buy: $90; uncommongoods.com.


Box of Chocolate Soaps

Trade in the box of chocolates this year for a set of homemade soaps that are infused with cocoa powder and essential oils. Not only feel do they feel good on your skin, but they smell amazing, too.

To buy: $28; uncommongoods.com.


Make Your Own Chocolate Truffles Kit

Make it a date by baking this decadent treat together! The kit includes all the ingredients and instructions to make about 36 truffles.

To buy: $35; uncommongoods.com.


We Found Each Other Custom Puzzle

Commemorate where you first met with this 300-piece puzzle that you can personalize with an aerial image of the city where it all began.

To buy: $129; uncommongoods.com.


The Story of Us

Cherish your life story and memories forever by recording them in this special 88-page, linen-bound journal that includes photo corners for mounting your favorite pictures.

To buy: $35; uncommongoods.com.


Cabernet Sauvignon Wine Making Kit

Spend Valentine’s Day together with her true love—wine! With this kit that’s complete with a wine-making guide, you’ll have enough wine for five 750-ml bottles.

To buy: $60; uncommongoods.com.


What I Love About You By Me Book

Fill in the blanks in this 112-page book with special memories and little things that you love about her.

To buy: $10; uncommongoods.com.


Heart Vases

Flowers on Valentine’s Day are fine, but they’re even better when they come in hand-blown glass heart-shaped vases.

To buy: $25; uncommongoods.com.


Personalized Picnic Table Wine Carrier

Dream of warmer days with this handcrafted wood wine carrier that transforms into a portable mini picnic table. Engrave it with your last name or anniversary to make it an even more memorable gift.

To buy: $150; uncommongoods.com.


Reclaimed Wood Cookbook Stand

If she loves to cook or bake, this cookbook stand made from beautiful reclaimed wood will be her new favorite kitchen accessory. It can hold traditional cookbooks, a tablet, or a handwritten recipe.

To buy: $95; uncommongoods.com.


Calming Lavender Heat Pillow

This pillow filled with lavender and barley will help calm her nerves if she's stressed out easily. Just pop it into the microwave for about two minutes and place on your back, neck, or shoulders to instantly feel its relaxing effects.

To buy: $35; uncommongoods.com.


Wine Soaps

Perfect for wine lovers, this set of four wine-inspired soaps are actually all-vegan and are made from several natural ingredients including olive oil, coconut oil, cocoa butter oil, shea butter oil, and more that guarantee extra soft skin.

To buy: $28; uncommongoods.com.


Bedside Essentials Pocket

She won’t have to worry about looking for her reading glasses again thanks to this super helpful pocket that comes in two different sizes.

To buy: from $16; uncommongoods.com.


Multicolor Ombre Stemless Wine Glass Set

Upgrade her wine glasses on her bar cart with this artisan-made set. These six stemless glasses each come in a different color and work great for cocktails or wine.

To buy: $85; uncommongoods.com.