We tried 157 items—seriously. These six will satisfy your autumn cravings and make you feel cozy all season long.
Each product we feature has been independently selected and reviewed by our editorial team. If you make a purchase using the links included, we may earn commission.
Advertisement
1119rtf-caramel-apple-butter
Credit: stonewallkitchen.com

As soon as the clock strikes midnight on September 1, all things pumpkin spice appear as if out of thin air. And for good reason—the sweet, spicy combination of cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, cloves, and allspice is deliciously reminiscent of everything we love about autumn, like cozy sweaters, fall foliage, and football season. But let's not limit ourselves to pumpkin spice: there are many other seasonal flavors that evoke that warm-and-tingling fall feeling, like cranberry, cinnamon, maple, and more. That's why we tested 157 fall-flavored items to find these six winners. We promise they'll satisfy your autumn cravings and make you feel cozy all season long.

Terra Sweet Potato Chips
Credit: Courtesy of manufacturer

1 Best Sweet Potato: Terra Sweet Potato Chips

Made with just three ingredients (sweet potatoes, vegetable oil, and sea salt), these chips have an ideal balance of sweet and salty. The thick-cut ripples give them a sturdy crunch, so serve them with your favorite dip or alongside a bowl of chili.

To buy: $3; amazon.com.

Whole Foods Market 365 Spiced Pumpkin Pancake and Waffle Mix
Credit: Courtesy of manufacturer

2 Best Pumpkin Spice: Whole Foods Market 365 Spiced Pumpkin Pancake and Waffle Mix

A fall upgrade on a classic. With buttermilk and real pumpkin, this mix makes holiday breakfasts a breeze.

To buy: $5; amazon.com.

McConnell’s Fine Ice Creams Cinnamon & Oatmeal Raisin Cookies
Credit: Courtesy of manufacturer

3 Best Cinnamon: McConnell’s Fine Ice Creams Cinnamon & Oatmeal Raisin Cookies

Swirled with cinnamon, this ice cream is made with grass-fed milk and packed with chunks of freshly baked cookies.

To buy: $12; mcconnells.com.

Base Culture Maple Almond Butter
Credit: Courtesy of manufacturer

4 Best Maple: Base Culture Maple Almond Butter

Sweetened with maple sugar, this chunky nut butter is loaded with crushed almonds. Stir it into oatmeal or spread it on toast for a morning treat.

To buy: 6 for $42; amazon.com.

Stonewall Kitchen Caramel Apple Butter
Credit: Courtesy of manufacturer

5 Best Apple: Stonewall Kitchen Caramel Apple Butter

This decadent spread tastes like apple pie in a jar. Enjoy it as a topping for baked fruit and ice cream, or spread it on slabs of spiced cake.

To buy: $8; stonewallkitchen.com.

Vermont Creamery Cranberry, Orange & Cinnamon Goat Cheese
Credit: Courtesy of manufacturer

6 Best Cranberry: Vermont Creamery Cranberry, Orange & Cinnamon Goat Cheese

Tangy and fruity, this versatile log is great crumbled over salads or as the centerpiece of your Thanksgiving cheese board.

To buy: $5; instacart.com.