The Best Olive Oils

Mild and versatile, these won’t overwhelm your ingredients.

Best Budget

California Olive Ranch Fresh California Extra Virgin
This all-American pick wowed testers with its smooth, subtle taste—think gentle apple notes with a hint of spice.

To buy: $9 for 500 milliliters, at supermarkets.

Academia Barilla 100 Percent Organic Extra Virgin
Creamy and balanced, it’s as close as you can get to eating a bowl of fat, juicy green olives.

To buy: $14 for 500 milliliters, at supermarkets.

Rich and nuanced, these add flavor to salads and finished dishes.

Best Budget

Partanna Sicilian Extra Virgin 
This buttery, unfiltered selection is sold in a large, budget-friendly tin. Use it over grilled vegetables and fish.

To buy: $15 for 1 liter, at Whole Foods Markets and specialty food stores.

Nuñez de Prado Extra Virgin
A knockout: Prepare for bright, clear notes of mint and citrus with mild toasted-walnut undertones. Perfect on pasta.

To buy: $14 for 500 milliliters, at supermarkets.

Lungarotti DOP Umbria
This winner starts with a tart burst, slides into a grassy sweetness, and finishes with a refreshing, peppery bite.

To buy: $25 for 250 milliliters, hausfortuna.com.

See all Daily Finds from this month