4 Crazy Delicious Takes on the Classic Peanut Butter Cookie
From super-crunch to salty-sweet, these creative cookies will become new household favorites.
Not only are we bringing you a brand new peanut butter cookie recipe (our easiest, tastiest one yet), but we also turned it into a choose-your-own-adventure dessert. Peanut lovers will want to try the super-crunch cookie, packed with salty chopped peanuts. Fans of salty-sweet desserts will fall in love with our chocolate and pretzel-packed cookies (made with two types of chocolate). Coffee addicts will go nuts for our espresso sea salt variety, while anyone who loves a great dessert mash-up (a la the cronut) will appreciate our peanut butter and oatmeal raisin hybrid. Try one or try them all—with a recipe this easy, it will be hard to stop at just one variety.
We used the entire jar of peanut butter in these easy, 5-ingredient cookies, meaning they’re packed with peanut butter flavor and you skip the mess of measuring sticky peanut butter. Simply spoon the entire jar into a bowl, stir in the remaining ingredients, roll into balls, and bake until golden. You’ll never want (or need) to do it any other way.
Get the recipe: One-Bowl Peanut Butter Cookies + 4 Variations
If you crave even more peanut flavor than the classic cookie provides, try stirring chopped salted peanuts into the dough. The result is a cookie with extra salt and crunch—perfect for true peanut fanatics.
To create these extra-special peanut butter cookies, we began by stirring espresso powder and flaky sea salt into the dough. But we knew we could take it one step further, so we rolled the dough balls in a mixture of sugar, instant espresso, and flaky salt. The result is a shimmering cookie filled with bold espresso flavor.
If you’ve ever had cinnamon peanut butter, you know the combination is downright addictive. We upped the ante by folding in oats and raisins, creating a kitchen-sink style cookie with a peanut butter base.
Why add one type of chocolate when you could add two? We stirred in both milk and semi-sweet chocolate chunks for the ultimate salty-sweet peanut butter cookie (there’s pretzels in there, too). If you can, buy bars of chocolate and chop them yourself—you’ll get a variety of sizes (including deliciously thin shards), making for more interesting cookies.