Yes, those are Andes mints on top.
With Christmas just a little more than one month away, it’s time to start thinking about this year’s cookie lineup. Whether you’re baking for a cookie swap, a potluck, or as an activity with the kids, you’ll want to decide which direction to take. Gingerbread men or iced sugar cookies? Twice-baked biscotti or Italian thumbprint? Though you really can’t go wrong, you’re sure to be satisfied with Andes Mint Cookies—the most popular Christmas cookie on Pinterest this year.
While thin and crispy cookies have their time and place, there’s something about a soft and chewy chocolate cookie that hits all the right notes. But these aren't your average soft-baked cookies. For a double dose of mint flavor (a classic during the holidays), each cookie is filled with pieces of Andes mints, then topped with more mints while still warm from the oven. The technique is pretty genius: After the Andes mints melt on the freshly-baked cookies, you’ll spread the melted chocolate all over the top of the cookies to create a shiny, swirled finish. (A mini offset spatula will help you spread it evenly). Enjoy them warm, or let cool completely, and package them in pretty tins.
RELATED: Basic Sugar Cookie Dough
Not a fan of chocolate cookies? This trick will work with any cookie flavor (snickerdoodles, sugar, etc). To ensure you end up with a soft and chewy texture, be sure to beat the room-temperature butter until it's very pale in color. When you add in the sugars, continue to beat until the mixture is creamy and fluffy. As you beat, air is whipped into the dough, creating the soft-baked cookie you're after.
For endless cookie inspiration, check out our comprehensive cookie calendar.