11 Cream Cheese Substitutes to Try if You're All Out of Schmear

No cream cheese? Whether it's a good schmear for your bagel or making a dessert, these cream cheese alternatives could be a perfect choice.

If cheesecake or dip is on your party menu, but you or your grocery store are out of cream cheese, you're in luck. There are a variety of substitutes for cream cheese that offer the same creamy vibe, including some tasty plant-based alternatives if you're looking to go dairy-free. Just stock up on a cheesecloth, a few lemons, and plan ahead; some options require a little extra time and effort to be perfect for your recipe.

01 of 11

Neufchâtel Cheese

Cream cheese's lower-fat cousin is often used interchangeably with regular cream cheese and works beautifully in most cream cheese recipes.

02 of 11

Greek Yogurt

Greek Yogurt in a Bowl with Spoon

Plain Greek yogurt has the same creaminess and tang as cream cheese—and straining it overnight gives it a more solid texture. It's a great alternative for many recipes requiring cream cheese.

03 of 11

Mascarpone Cheese

Jar of mascarpone with an open-faced tomato sandwich on the side
Chef John

This sweeter, creamier cheese is an easy swap in most recipes—in fact, cream cheese is often cited as a mascarpone substitute. If you miss the tang, add a little squeeze of lemon.

04 of 11

Vegan Cream Cheese

Vegan cream cheese is a good substitute (we love Kite Hill, in particular). For best results in baking, use a recipe specifically for vegan cheese. (The manufacturers' websites have some great options!)

05 of 11

Labneh

Overhead view of a plate of labneh with zatar pita chips surrounded by a grocery store container of labneh, a bowl of zatar, and a plate of pita chips

Serious Eats / Amanda Suarez

This tasty, creamy Middle Eastern cheese made of thickened yogurt is a wonderful replacement for cream cheese. (Try our tasty labneh dip recipe.)

06 of 11

Cottage Cheese

Cottage Cheese and Pineapple in a Pink Bowl with a Metal Spoon

Verywell / Alexandra Shytsman

The texture may not seem right, but a quick whirl in the blender or food processor gives cottage cheese a smoother texture. Add lemon for a little tang and drain in a cheesecloth if it's still too runny. (Using full-fat cottage cheese helps with thickness.)

07 of 11

Ricotta Cheese

Easy and Delicious Homemade Ricotta Cheese

Just like cottage cheese, this swap requires a little effort to be cream-cheese perfect. Blend, drain, and add a squeeze of lemon and a few pinches of salt to make it more cream cheese-like. Bonus: Make ricotta cheese at home with milk and ingredients you probably already have on hand.

08 of 11

Silken Tofu

Package of silken tofu

Lori Rice

Another plant-based alternative to cream cheese, silken tofu needs a little lemon and salt to achieve the same flavor profile. For cheesecake, swap your usual recipe for a vegan one that calls for tofu.

09 of 11

Goat Cheese

Goat cheese varieties on a black board

Danielle Daly

Goat cheese tends to be more crumbly than cream cheese. For it to work as a substitute, mix in a little heavy cream to get that cream cheese consistency.

10 of 11

Cashews

Bowl of roasted and salted cashew nuts on slate
Westend61 / Getty Images

Nuts seem like an odd choice to replace cream cheese, but once they're softened and blended, you get that same creamy texture. To soften cashews: Soak them overnight or, if you're in a hurry, soak them in boiling water for 30 minutes. (Check out our cashew ricotta recipe, which makes a nice substitute.)

Many vegan cheesecake recipes use softened cashews—and it's best to follow one of those rather than your favorite dairy cheesecake recipe.

11 of 11

Sour Cream

Sour cream makes a great cream cheese substitute in dips and spreads—but it may not be suitable for dessert recipes.

Was this page helpful?
Related Articles