Our team tasted more than 70 varieties of sauces, spreads, and relishes to see what squeezed out the competition.

By Ananda Eidelstein
June 21, 2018
Each product we feature has been independently selected and reviewed by our editorial team. If you make a purchase using the links included, we may earn commission.


Zingy and bold, with just enough structure from ground-up mustard seeds, this classic is exactly what we want on hot dogs and sausages.

To buy: $1.50 for 12 oz.; target.com.

Whole Foods


The right balance of sweetness, tang, and smoke makes this pick as good on ribs as it is on grilled salmon.

To buy: $4 for 17.5 oz.; at Whole Foods.



Even the mayo haters loved this super-creamy spread. Never clumpy or oily, it gets bonus points for using 100 percent cage-free eggs.

To buy: $4 for 30 oz.; walmart.com.

Woodstock Organic


This cucumber-free jalapeño relish has a hint of sweetness and a big kick. It licked the competition (most of which were full of dyes and high-fructose corn syrup).

To buy: $7 for 16 oz.; amazon.com.

Kensington and Sons


The first ingredient in this premium ketchup is whole tomatoes, not tomato concentrate. We were not only surprised but converted.

To buy: $5 for 20 oz.; target.com.

Baumer Foods


Made with only three ingredients, this bright all-purpose sauce is bursting with complex flavor from aged cayenne peppers. Keep the pretty bottle on the table for a dash of heat whenever you want it.

To buy: $2 for 12 oz.; walmart.com.