Say goodbye to raccoon eyes for good!

By Rebecca Carhart
Updated April 09, 2019
Each product we feature has been independently selected and reviewed by our editorial team. If you make a purchase using the links included, we may earn commission.

While removing your makeup is never as fun as applying it, it’s still one of the most important steps in your skincare routine. You probably already have a favorite makeup remover, but if you notice irritation when removing eye makeup or find that even the most powerful makeup removers can’t wipe off your waterproof mascara and eyeliner, it might be time to invest in a specially-formulated eye makeup remover.

Aside from gently removing even the most stubborn budge-proof eye makeup in a snap, most of these magic erasers provide additional skincare benefits as well. Some are designed to strengthen your eyelashes, while others leave the sensitive skin around your eyes feeling more hydrated and refreshed.

With so many options available, it feel overwhelming to find the best one for your needs. To help you cut through the clutter, we’ve combed through hundreds of eye makeup removers to see which ones customers can’t stop raving about. These best-selling products not only have an overwhelming number of glowing reviews, but they also have thousands of five-star ratings between them.

From cleansing wipes to creamy balms and oil-free options, keep reading to see which eye makeup removers customers love the most. Whether you’re fixing a small eyeliner mistake or taking off your makeup at the end of the day, these will get the job done in record time.

Over 3,500 Sephora customers are fans of this eye makeup remover by Klorane. The plant-based product is specially formulated to quickly dissolve even the most budge-proof eye makeup while strengthening lashes and soothing the sensitive skin around your eyes. Many of the five-star reviews called it the “best eye makeup remover,” with one saying, “This is an excellent and gentle waterproof eye makeup remover. The product is truly gentle on the eyes without leaving an oily residue. It does not burn and I do not find any lashes falling out using this product. I will be repurchasing for sure!”

To buy: $16;

If you hate spending a lot of time removing your eye makeup at the end of the day, reach for one of these quick and easy cleansing eye pads by Simple. The wipes are infused with micellar water to hydrate skin while gently removing eye makeup. Over 890 Amazon customers love that the wipes easily dissolve waterproof eye makeup without leaving behind a greasy residue or any signs of irritation. “These Simple wipes are, without a doubt, the best face wipes I have ever used. I have seen a noticeable improvement in my skin since I started using micellar water products. These wipes remove stubborn, waterproof eye makeup with a single swipe. Perfect for my sensitive skin. No sticky feeling, residue, or film left behind,” said one happy customer.

To buy: $10;

Looking for an eye makeup remover that lets you fix small mistakes without starting over? Check out this eraser pen from Lashfood. The powerful remover can dissolve even the most stubborn waterproof eye makeup without irritating your delicate eye area. “This product is a must-have for anyone who wears mascara or eye makeup,” said one five-star review. “You know when you’re applying mascara and a few dots or smudges land on your eyelid or fallout from eyeshadow appears on your cheekbone? This little magic wand makes them disappear immediately, without removing or smudging the shadow or concealer below. Love, love, love it.”

To buy: $18;

This affordable Neutrogena option proves you don’t have to spend a ton of money on an effective, non-irritating eye makeup remover. The oil-free formula is beloved by shoppers because it doesn’t sting or leave behind greasy residue. It is also dermatologist-developed and ophthalmologist-tested, so you know it is safe to use on all skin types. One happy customer said, “This is an excellent, gentle eye makeup remover that does the job without irritating eyes. So much less expensive than big-name cosmetic names. I enjoy the product and thinking how much money I'm saving by choosing this Neutrogena product.”

To buy: $6;

This innovative makeup removing product by Clinique starts out as a solid balm but turns into an oil when applied to skin. While you can use it all over your face, it has been ophthalmologist-tested and specially formulated to gently remove even the toughest waterproof mascaras. The paraben-free product has over 900 reviews at Ulta and an impressive 4.7-star rating. Ninety-four percent of Ulta customers say they love the eye makeup remover so much they would recommend it to others.

To buy: $30;

If you have sensitive eyes and are worried about irritating them, try this eye makeup remover by Sephora Collection. The fast-acting formula was tested by ophthalmologists, so you know it’s suitable to use on even the most sensitive skin. Not only does it gently remove waterproof eye makeup with one swipe, but the product is also infused with flavonoids and olive wood extracts which strengthen your lashes at the same time. The beloved eye makeup remover has over 60,000 likes and 3,500 reviews at Sephora.

To buy: $11;

In the market for an effective eye makeup remover that won’t bother your contact lenses? Over 1,000 Amazon shoppers recommend this option by Mary Kay. The ophthalmologist-tested product is fragrance-free and non-comedogenic, so it won’t irritate or cause breakouts around the delicate area near your eyes. One of the many five-star reviews read, “It removes my eyeliner, mascara, and eyebrow pencil quickly and without much rubbing...even the waterproof products. It has never irritated my eyes either, even when I wear my contacts. I highly recommend this product.”

To buy: $17;

Who doesn’t love a multifaceted beauty product? This beloved product by Bliss pulls double duty by working as both a regular cleanser and an eye makeup remover at the same time. The milky jelly formula gently removes dirt and stubborn makeup and leaves skin feeling soft and hydrated. “This cleanser literally melts off all the makeup that's in my skin. It's so easy to get off the stubborn mascara and eye makeup. I love the rose water smell and how clean it leaves my skin,” raved one Ulta customer.

To buy: $9 (originally $12);

With over 40,000 likes and 3,000 reviews, this Lancôme eye makeup remover is one of the most popular options at Sephora. Simply shake the bottle to activate, then swipe over your eyes to remove any and all eye makeup. The gentle formula has been ophthalmologist-tested and works great on even the most sensitive of skin. “This eye makeup remover is the best on the market,” said one reviewer. “It removes eye makeup with the least amount of effort and leaves the eye area moisturized. I've tried many different kinds of eye makeup removers hoping to find one as gentle and effective for less money, but I haven't found one that compares. It is definitely worth the money and it lasts a long time.”

To buy: $30;