Give your makeup bag a budget-friendly upgrade.

By Jayla Andrulonis
January 09, 2020
Each product we feature has been independently selected and reviewed by our editorial team. If you make a purchase using the links included, we may earn commission.

My beloved Beautyblender recently fell victim to the slobbery jaws of my aunt and uncle's golden retriever, who decided a peek into my makeup bag was on the day’s agenda during their visit. With the drool-soaked sponge in hand, I contemplated whether washing it would suffice, but soon realized it was time to let the already-expired life of my sponge meet its final fate. But in the wake of the post-holiday chaos that is my bank account, I decided to forgo my typical Sephora haul for a more budget-friendly alternative. 

After a quick Amazon search for makeup sponges, I was met with literally hundreds of options to choose from as a replacement for my Beautyblender. I quickly added the best-selling option to my cart to expedite the Prime two-day shipping window, only to then fall down a rabbit hole of similar options with their own stellar reputations. If you, too, are in the market for a new beauty sponge that won’t put a dent in your bank account, check out the list of my findings, below. Based on enthusiastic reviews and high ratings, shoppers have named these sponges comparable—if not better than—the cult-fave Beautyblender.  

So whether your makeup bag is in need of a new year upgrade or your go-to met a similarly unfortunate beauty-sponge-as-dog-toy demise, keep reading to browse the six best makeup sponges you can shop on Amazon for under $20.

Best Overall: BEAKEY Makeup Sponge Set (Set of 5)

This 5-piece set of vibrant sponges took the spot of my Beautyblender after the dog slobber fiasco, and I couldn’t be happier with how well the quality has stacked up. Aside from the sponge's ability to give me what appears to be a flawless complexion after applying just a few drops of my favorite foundation, knowing that I have four more waiting for me when it’s time for a replacement makes me feel uncharacteristically prepared. 

To buy: $9;

Best For Sensitive Skin: JUNO & Co. Microfiber Velvet Sponge (Set of 4)

Made with antimicrobial microfiber material, JUNO & Co.’s sponge set is designed to apply loose powders, highlighters, concealers, and liquid products with a velvety smooth, dream-like feel. What’s more, the gentle, non-abrasive material is ideal for sensitive skin that’s prone to breakouts or irritation. 

To buy: $12;

Best Beautyblender Dupe: Aesthetica Cosmetics Beauty Sponge Blender

Looking through reviews of the Aesthetica Cosmetics Beauty Sponge Blender, comparisons to the Beautyblender are mentioned repeatedly—and it’s easy to see why. Casual users and professional makeup artists alike swear by this option as a trusted dupe for the pricier original thanks to its soft finish, ability to quickly soak up water, and the overall ease in which it blends foundation. 

To buy: $4;

Best Budget Option: Beauty Junkees Pro Beauty Sponge Makeup Blenders (Set of 4)

While a Beautyblender will cost you $20 for just one sponge, this budget-friendly option by Beauty Junkee comes in at $15 and has you covered with four specialized sponges  designed for contouring, highlighting, applying foundation, and blending. Even better? Beauty lovers who’ve swapped their Beautyblenders for this affordable set say they’re a breeze to clean.   

To buy: $15;

Best Sustainable Option: EcoTools Perfecting Blender Duo

If you’re looking to kick off the new year with sustainable beauty top of mind, this duo by EcoTools is a great place to start. The cruelty-free sponges are made from recycled aluminum and plastic materials, while the packaging is designed with tree-free gentle cotton and bamboo fibers. Shoppers have called the sponges “firm yet plush” and vouch for their ability to create a dewy, flawless finish. 

To buy: $6;

Best Drugstore Find: L'Oréal Paris Makeup Infallible Blend Artist Makeup Blender Sponge

This makeup sponge by drugstore favorite L'Oréal has an easy-grip design to help streamline the application process, whether you opt for a few dots of BB cream or a full-coverage look. And you won’t have to worry about replacing a broken sponge anytime soon with this durable pick; Amazon shoppers say the blender holds up to repeated cleanings “like a dream,” so you can count on it for months to come. 

To buy: $7;