Peary & Henson Aftershave Splash
Named after the first explorers to reach the North Pole, this non-alcoholic concoction mixes astringent witch hazel with softening aloe, making skin feel both firm and soft. The retro bottle will look great on his counter, too. One historic note: When Robert Peary finally reached the Pole, he wrote that his triumph seemed “just like every day.” Just like shaving, in other words.
To buy: $18, prospectorco.com.