Winner: The Original Super Glue All-Purpose White Glue

The tube’s “super-narrow tip” and the way it left paper “dry, not soggy” impressed testers.
To Buy: $1.80 for two .35-ounce tubes.

Runner-Up: Elmer’s Glue-all Multi-purpose Glue

This glue, familiar to students for nearly 60 years, “works every time,” said a tester.
To Buy: $2.30 for 7.6 ounces.