Cattlemen’s Award Winning Classic Barbecue Sauce

A sauce for ketchup lovers, this kid-friendly blend is similar to what you’d find in many chain restaurants. “It has a nice balance of sugar and tang,” said one person. “It’s thick enough for dipping fries,” said another. The glaze also got points for looks: The amber color is “beautiful,” one fan enthused.
To Buy: $2.50 for 18 ounces.