Tips and Tricks: A plain mirror can have an expensive custom look when you paint it a color that coordinates with others in the room, says Edward Schaefer, a decorative painter in North Bergen, New Jersey. To work most effectively, position the mirror so you can paint evenly around the edges. Place a small mirror over a sturdy bowl or a large one on a small stool, and put down newspapers to catch spatters. Using a brush the approximate width of the frame will help minimize dripping.

Best Paint for the Job: A paint with a glossy finish will give a frame “a little sheen,” says DIY Network's Cathie Filian. Interior designer Robert LaHatt suggests adding a few coats of clear varnish for a lacquered effect.

RS Pick: Pratt & Lambert Paints Pro-Hide Gold high-gloss www.prattandlambert.com for retailers.