Winner

Kiehl’s Imperiale Moisturizing Cuticle Treatment, $19
This rich balm soothes dry cuticles with hydrating avocado oil, squalene, and vitamin E, and it contains exfoliating vitamin A to smooth rough skin. It also scored points for staying put.
To Buy: www.kiehls.com.

Runner-Up

Haken Cuticle Oil, $4
Made with vitamins A, D, and E and essential oils. Comes in six pleasing scents.
To Buy: www.sallybeauty.com for locations.