Winner: Shu Uemura Fiberxtension Mascara, $23

This rich formula doesn’t just enhance. It contains tiny fibers that act as discreet, seamless false lashes, adding length and volume. “People asked if my lashes were real,” a tester reported.
To Buy: www.shuuemura-usa.com

Runner-Up: Clinique High Definition Lashes Mascara, $13.50

The dual wand has an effective brush, but the comb may overcoat lashes.
To Buy: www.clinque.com