Winner

American Flatbread Tomato Sauce and Three Cheese
None of the testers could believe this pizza came from the freezer. Partially baked in a wood-fired oven, it has an “enticing garlicky aroma,” an “artisanal look,” a “perfectly crisp crust,” and an “amazing real-cheese and fresh-herb taste” that had many tasters asking for seconds.
To Buy: $7.50 for a 9.1-ounce pizza (2 servings), available in most supermarkets and natural-food stores nationwide.