Best Overall

Skippy

Spread the Word: Testers loved Skippy's original Creamy, calling it the "smooth, nutty" stuff of childhood memories. "This is how you remember peanut butter!" declared one fan. Pass the celery, please.

Sticking Points: Skippy's newer spin-offs didn't fare quite as well. The Roasted Honey Nut variety was deemed "too sweet," and it was plagued by a stale-peanut taste. The word on Reduced Fat was that it had reduced taste and an "artificial sweetener flavor" that did nothing to override the blandness.