Winner

Erno Laszlo Sea Mud Exfoliating Mask, $45
Kaolin clay and sea mud loosen dead cells from the skin’s surface, uncovering the smoother texture underneath. The gentle combo (shown) works for sensitive skin, and “it wasn’t drippy or cakey, like some muds,” said a tester.
To Buy: www.ernolaszlo.com.

Runner-Up

Murad Exfoliating Fruit Enzyme Mask, $30
Papaya- and pineapple-juice enzymes work as exfoliants, gently dissolving dry, dull cells. Staffers liked the mask’s gel formula, which felt “smooth,” not gritty or abrasive.
To Buy: www.murad.com.