Winner

Bioré Blemish Fighting Ice Cleanser, $6
“It helped manage breakouts and got rid of shine,” said one panelist. Lavender soothes skin irritated by drying acne products, while salicylic acid keeps pores clean.
To Buy: At drugstores.

Runner-Up

Lancôme Gel Clarté, $21
This gel foams up when it comes in contact with water, but users say it rinses off without residue. One tester even reported, “My skin seemed to produce less oil when I used this.”
To Buy: www.lancome-usa.com.