Uplands Cheese Company Rush Creek Reserve
This ultra-creamy cheese from Wisconsin is aged in a strip of bark, which gives it a delicious, smoky flavor. Cut off the top and set it out with a spoon and crackers for a decadent hors d’oeuvre.
To buy: $28 for one 12-ounce cheese, uplandscheese.com. Order by December 19th for delivery by December 24th.