Good things come in small packages, as the age-old saying goes—and never is that more true than during the holiday season when, every year, stores and sites are filled with a big bounty of toys and trinkets to stuff the family’s Christmas stockings. And let’s not forget: No longer is the stocking stuffer a humble secondary gift to the main ones; these days, it’s just as key to the season’s festivities. The right stocking stuffer picks can make your Christmas morning way more memorable (those shrieks of excitement when your kid joyfully opens a winner!)—but sifting through all the options and making each and every buying decision can be overwhelming. Never fear: We have saved you tons of time and trouble by culling the market for the very best finds, all priced under $25. Our editor-approved offerings run the gamut, from classic and crowd-pleasing to quirky to creative. Click through Real Simple’s extensive gallery, and you’ll find a carefully curated collection of all kinds of goodies: decadent foodie indulgences (like Matcha tea spread), purse-size beauty buys (glittery nail polish pens and eye palettes for everyone!), fun kiddie couture (like retro baby socks), clever kitchen helpers (a pizza cutter shaped like a Vespa!), tongue-in-cheek techie tools (a wrench-style smartphone stand) and lots more. Whether you’re shopping for little ones, tweens, teens, or adults–or, very likely, all of the above—you’ll find your ideal stocking stuffers right here. Sit back; browse Real Simple’s big, wide-ranging roundup; and get ready to check everyone off your list.