Unsalted Winner

Joseph’s Sugar-Free Creamy Valencia

For panelists who like their peanut butter pure (without even salt), this brand’s creamy consistency and intense taste won high marks. It glided on easily without seeming oily.
To buy: $3 for 18 ounces.

Note: Some batches of this product were recalled on September 24, 2012. Please check the FDA's website for full recall information.